Monday, May 04, 2020

No Need to Specify Evidence Upon Which Supervised Release Revocation Is Based

US v. Patterson: Patterson was in a local jail while also serving a term of supervised release when his cellmate overdosed and was taken to the hospital. Patterson was eventually charged with violating his conditions of supervised release by possessing heroin and Xanax with intent to distribute as a result of that incident. He denied the charges and the district court held a contested revocation hearing in which it heard testimony from the cellmate (he got better) and others. The district court concluded that Patterson had provided the drugs the cellmate used to overdose, revoked his term of supervised release, and imposed a term of 39 months in prison.

On appeal, the Fourth Circuit affirmed Patterson’s revocation, but vacated his sentence. As to the revocation, the court rejected Patterson’s argument that the district court violated his due process rights by not specifying the particular evidence upon which it based its decision to revoke his term of supervised release. That was because “the record plainly shows the trial court’s rationale” in the way it “actively engaged with the witnesses and counsel.” The court also found the district court’s conclusion was not clearly erroneous. As to the sentence, however, the court agreed with Patterson that the district court did not provide a sufficient explanation for the sentence it imposed, because while it “gave a fulsome explanation” of the 3553(a) factors it “failed to not that it had considered Patterson’s mitigation points.”

Monday, April 27, 2020

Court Must Apply Retroactive Law to Career Offender Designation in 1SA Proceeding


US v. Chambers: In 2005 Chambers was convicted as a career offender to 262 months in prison after being convicted of a crack conspiracy. Two of his prior predicate convictions were for North Carolina drug offenses for which, because of the state’s then-existing guideline scheme, he did not actually face a maximum sentence of more than one year. Under Fourth Circuit law at the time, however, they counted as predicates. More recently, Chambers filed for relief under the First Step Act’s retroactive application of the Fair Sentencing Act and argued that the district court should correct the original career offender designation in light of Simmons. The district court declined to do so and did not reduce Chambers’ sentence.

A divided Fourth Circuit reversed the district court. The court rejected the Government’s position that the 1SA only allowed the district court to make “statutory Fair Sentencing Act adjustments and preclude[d] it from correcting Guideline errors,” noting that Section 404(b) of the 1SA uses the term “impose” a sentence, rather than “modify” or “reduce.” When imposing a sentence “a court does not simply adjust the statutory minimums; it must also recalculate the Guideline range.” Unlike the language of 18 U.S.C. 3582(c)(2), there are no limitations on doing do under 3582(c)(1), the mechanism for applying the 1SA. Of particular import in this case was that the change in the law that occurred in Simmons had been made retroactive, so that the career offender designation was “as wrong today as it was in 2005.” The court also explained (in noting Government concessions) that the usual 3553(a) factors apply in 1SA proceedings and that courts may consider a defendant’s post-sentencing conduct in determining whether and to what extent to reduce a sentence.

Judge Rushing dissented, arguing that Guideline calculations are not part of what is “expressly permitted” by the 1SA and noted that the court, while making Simmons retroactive the context of challenges to a felon-in-possession conviction, reached the opposite conclusion with regard to Guideline calculations in 2255 proceedings.

Congrats to the Defender office in Western NC on the win!

Abandonment, Search Pursuant to Arrest Save Gun Conviction


US v. Ferebee: Ferebee was at the home of a friend who was on probation when officers arrived to perform a warrantless search. Ferebee was sitting on a sofa, smoking marijuana, against which a black backpack was resting. He stood up, “picked up the backpack with his left hand, and held it out as another officer” patted him down (finding nothing). When asked if there were any weapons in the bag, Ferebee “stated that the bag was not actually his.” Ferebee was arrested for marijuana possession and taken outside while another officer searched the backpack, in which they found a gun. Ferebee later gave a statement where he said that the backpack, and the gun, were his. He unsuccessfully moved to suppress the gun, then entered a conditional guilty plea to one count of being a felon in possession of a firearm.

A divided Fourth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of Ferebee’s motion to suppress. First, the court agreed with the district court that Ferebee had no “standing” to challenge the search of the bag because he said that it wasn’t his. Specifically, the court rejected Ferebee’s attempt to utilize the collective knowledge doctrine, holding that it did not matter that the officer who searched the bag was not the one to whom Ferebee said the bag was not his. That is because the issue of abandonment of property “focuses solely on the intent of the defendant,” while “the collective-knowledge doctrine focuses solely on the knowledge of the police officers.” Here the “abandonment was complete when Ferebee told [the first officer[ that the backpack was not his.” The court also held that the district court’s conclusion that Ferebee had abandoned the backpack was not clearly erroneous. Second, the court held that even if Ferebee had standing the search was proper as done incident to a lawful arrest. Even though Ferebee was handcuffed and outside the house when the backpack was searched inside, the court concluded that there was “no impediment to Ferebee’s movement beyond the handcuffs” and it was “clear from the video” that he was “only a few feet outside the house and thus could reach the other officers and the backpack within seconds.”

Judge Floyd dissented, arguing that Ferebee did not abandon the bag and that the search-incident-to-arrest exception did not apply. In particular, he argued that while the facts surrounding the abandonment question were reviewed for clear error, “whether those findings amount abandonment as a matter of law” should be reviewed de novo.