Monday, March 16, 2020

Court Provided Insufficient Reasons for Rejecting Variance Argument


US v. Torres-Reyes: Torres-Reyes, a Mexican national, had been deported from the United States (once) and allowed to leave voluntarily (twice) before returning “undetected” to the United States in 2001. In 2006 he was charged in state court with a drug offense, but absconded while on bond. Ten years later, he was arrested again in state court, where he eventually pleaded guilty to multiple charges. He was then charged in federal court with illegal reentry, to which he also pleaded guilty. At sentencing, the district court rejected Torres-Reyes’s objection to a 1995 drug conviction being counted in his criminal history score, resulting in an advisory Guideline range of 37 to 46 months. The district court also declined to impose a downward variance, eventually sentencing Torres-Reyes to a term of 37 months in prison.

On appeal, the Fourth Circuit vacated Torres-Reyes’s sentence. It noted that while the district court provided a sufficient explanation for rejecting the legal objection Torres-Reyes made to the inclusion of the 1995 convictions in the Guideline calculations, it did not similarly grapple with the equitable argument that doing so resulted in an advisory Guideline range that overstated the seriousness of Torres-Reyes’s criminal history. Because it was not “patently obvious” that the district court considered the variance argument, the sentence had to be vacated and the case remanded for resentencing.

Congrats to the Defender Office in Eastern NC on the win!

Tuesday, March 03, 2020

Remand for Failure to Adequately Explain Need for Special Supervised Release Conditions


US v. Arbaugh: Arbaugh pleaded guilty to traveling in foreign commerce to engage in illicit sexual activity, based on travels to Haiti during which he abused several young boys. At sentencing, the district court overruled Arbaugh’s objection to the imposition of a two-point enhancement for undue influence of a minor and calculated the advisory Guideline range to be 235 to 295 months in prison. The district court imposed a sentence of 276 months, after both Arbaugh and the Government argued for variances (in opposite directions). For Arbaugh’s lifetime term of supervised release the district court also imposed special conditions that he submit to warrants searches of his computer and related devices and prohibit him from owning encryption materials.

On appeal, the Fourth Circuit affirmed Arbaugh’s sentence of imprisonment, but vacated and remanded with regards to the special conditions of his term of supervised release. As to the imprisonment, the court first affirmed the application of the two-level enhancement, concluding that it was no double counting a factor already considered by the base Guideline, because it was focused on influence rather than age itself (although age, per the Guideline Commentary, is relevant to determining influence). The court also concluded that the district court provided a sufficient explanation for the sentence of imprisonment it imposed and that the sentence was substantively reasonable. As to the lifetime term of supervised release, however, while the court affirmed the length of the term, it held that the district court failed to adequately explain several of the special conditions it imposed. In particular, the court rejected the Government’s attempt to save the conditions by pointing to evidence in the record that supports them because that could not substitute for explanations from the district as to why it imposed the specific conditions at issue.

Congrats to the Defender office in the WDVA on the (partial) win!

No Need for Search Warrant to ID Crime Being Investigated


US v. Blakeney: Blakeney was driving in Maryland (in a federal enclave) when he crossed a median and struck an oncoming car, injuring the other driver and killing the passenger in his car. As emergency responders worked to free Blakeney from the wreckage “he became combative and resisted their efforts,” leading one responder to tell police that “Blakeney appeared to be under the influence of alcohol and PCP.” An officer, who also smelled a “strong odor of an alcoholic beverage” into Blakeney’s car, obtained a search warrant by telephone to draw Blakeney’s blood. The results showed a BAC of 0.07, high enough “to impair psychomotor functions and delay reaction times.” Three weeks later, the officer also obtained a warrant (from a different judge) to search the “black box” from Blakeney’s car. The data showed that the car was going 79 miles per hour (in a 45 mph zone) at the time of the accident. After Blakeney unsuccessfully sought to suppress the evidence seized pursuant to both warrants he was convicted at trial on multiple counts and sentenced to 40 months in prison.

On appeal, the Fourth Circuit affirmed the denial of Blakeney’s motions to suppress. As to the blood-draw warrant, the court concluded that it was supported by probable cause. The court rejected Blakeney’s argument that the application described a regular traffic accident, rather than a crime, and that because the officer smelled alcohol in the car itself, rather than on Blakeney’s person, there was not a sufficient basis for a finding of probable cause. The court noted that an officer is not required to “rule out all innocent explanations for suspicious facts before seeking a warrant.” As to the black box warrant, the court also concluded it was supported by probable cause. It also rejected the argument, made about both warrants, that they were insufficient because neither identified the particular crime being investigated. The court held that “the premise of Blakeney’s argument – that a search warrant must specify the crime for which the executing officers may seek evidence – is mistaken.”